How to Make Book Club Cool Again (And Actually Fun)

I have loved reading for as long as I can remember. To the point where my mom had to intervene. She would limit how often I could go to the library because I would disappear into books and come back hours later like I had traveled somewhere else entirely. I read at the dinner table, in the car, under the covers with a flashlight. It was obsessive in the way only childhood passions can be. Books were my escape, my entertainment, my entire personality for a while.

Then life happened.

Somewhere between work schedules, social obligations, phones that never stop buzzing, and the pressure to always be doing something productive, reading quietly slipped to the bottom of my list. I still loved books, but loving something and prioritizing it are two very different things. Reading started to feel indulgent instead of essential. And book clubs, at least the way I had seen them done, felt stiff, dated, or like another obligation instead of something I actually wanted to look forward to.

That is what made me rethink the entire idea of a book club.

Not as a serious literary discussion group. Not as homework with wine. But as a social ritual that makes reading feel exciting again. Something cool, relaxed, flexible, and very much part of real life. This is my take on how to make book club fun, modern, and something people actually show up for.

Theme ideas for a book club that actually feels fun -

• Era-based nights like 90s nostalgia, old money classics, or modern romance chaos

• Genre swaps where everyone reads the same genre but different books

• A wild card month where the book is chosen last minute or picked blindly

• Silent start evenings where the first 10 minutes are spent reading or flipping through notes

• Book-to-screen nights where you compare the book to its movie or series adaptation

• Mood-based themes like sad girl lit, summer escapism, messy female leads, or comfort reads

• Short story or essay nights for low-commitment months

• Book swap or white-elephant style book exchange nights

---

Why Book Club Needed a Rebrand

The traditional book club format has a branding problem. For a lot of people, it brings up images of forced discussion, awkward silences, half the group not finishing the book, and one person dominating the conversation. It can feel rigid and oddly high pressure for something that is supposed to be enjoyable.

At the same time, people are craving slower hobbies. There is a real desire right now to unplug, to be present, to connect in ways that feel meaningful instead of transactional. Reading fits perfectly into that, but the structure around it needs to evolve.

A modern book club should feel like a gathering you would attend even if you had not finished every chapter. It should feel social first, intellectual second, and rigid never. Once I started approaching it that way, everything changed. Starting with the vibe, not the book One of the biggest shifts for me was realizing that the book does not have to be the star of the night. The vibe does.

When the energy feels relaxed and welcoming, people open up more. Conversations flow more naturally. And ironically, the book discussion gets better because no one feels like they are being tested.

This starts with how you frame the gathering. Calling it book club is fine, but the tone matters more than the label. Make it clear that this is a space to talk, snack, unwind, and connect, with the book as a shared thread rather than a strict agenda.

I have found that when people feel comfortable, they actually want to talk about what they read. When they feel judged or rushed, they shut down. The goal is not to prove you are well read. The goal is to enjoy reading again.

Choosing Books That Spark Conversation, Not Homework Energy

Not every good book makes a good book club book. That took me a while to accept.

Some books are beautiful but introspective in a way that does not translate well to group discussion. Others are dense and require a level of focus that feels unrealistic for people juggling full lives.

For book club, I lean toward books that spark opinions. Books that make you want to text someone mid chapter. Books with strong characters, moral tension, messy relationships, cultural commentary, or surprising twists.

Genre variety helps too. Mixing in fiction, memoirs, essays, or lighter reads keeps things fresh. It also removes the pressure to always read something heavy or profound. Fun books are allowed. Easy books are allowed. Skipping a month is allowed. Reading should feel like something you want to do, not something you are forcing yourself through.

Making It Feel Like an Event Without Overdoing It

There is this idea that hosting has to be expensive or perfectly styled. I do not buy into that at all.

Some of the best book club nights I have been part of were low effort in the best way. A cozy living room, a few candles, simple snacks, and people who actually wanted to be there.

What matters is intention, not excess.

You can make it feel special with small touches. A signature drink that loosely matches the book’s mood. A playlist playing softly in the background. A stack of conversation prompts on the table for when things stall. These details create atmosphere without turning it into a production.

The goal is not Pinterest perfection. It is comfort. When people feel at ease, they stay longer and talk more.

Letting Conversation Flow Naturally

One thing I stopped doing was structuring the discussion too tightly. No one wants to feel like they are in a meeting. Instead of going around the circle answering the same question, I prefer to open with one broad prompt and let the conversation unfold. Something like what stayed with you after finishing the book, or which character annoyed you the most and why.

From there, people jump in organically. Side conversations happen. Personal stories come up. The book becomes a bridge into bigger discussions about relationships, work, identity, or life in general.

That is where the magic is.

Sometimes the conversation barely sticks to the book, and that is fine. Reading brought everyone into the room. The connection is what keeps them coming back.

Creative Formats That Keep It Interesting

Doing the same thing every month can make even the best book club feel stale. Changing the format once in a while keeps the energy up. Some months, discussion can be the focus. Other months, it can be more activity based. A casual book exchange where everyone brings a favorite read to pass along. A silent reading start where everyone settles in quietly before talking. A movie night inspired by a book adaptation.

These shifts keep the group engaged without turning it into a gimmick. It also takes pressure off finishing every book, which makes people more likely to stay involved long term.

Book club should flex with people’s lives, not fight against them.

Food and Drinks Without the Pressure

Food matters, but it does not need to be complicated. I like the idea of tying snacks or drinks loosely to the book, but only if it feels fun, not forced. A simple spread that feels indulgent without requiring hours in the kitchen works best. Potluck style is also underrated. When everyone brings one thing, the host gets to actually enjoy the night instead of running around stressed.

Again, the focus is connection. No one is grading the menu.

Food ideas that feel elevated but not try-hard

• A signature drink tied loosely to the book’s vibe, cocktail or mocktail

• Charcuterie boards that lean simple but intentional, cheese, fruit, crackers, olives

• Bite-sized desserts like brownies, blondies, or mini cupcakes

• A potluck where everyone brings one small thing instead of a full dish

• Cozy drinks like chai, hot chocolate, or iced coffee depending on the season

• Finger foods that don’t require plates or cutlery

For me, book club has been the bridge back to reading. Not in the obsessive, all consuming way of my childhood, but in a way that fits into my adult life.

It gave reading a social context again. It reminded me that books are meant to be talked about, not just consumed alone. It made reading feel like something I get to do, not something I should be doing.

That shift matters.

---

Making book club cool is not about reinventing reading. It is about removing the pressure that makes people avoid it in the first place.

When book club feels relaxed, flexible, and genuinely enjoyable, people show up. They read more. They talk more. They connect more.

At its best, book club is not about finishing chapters or having the smartest take in the room. It is about carving out time for stories, conversation, and shared moments in lives that are otherwise full and fast.

And honestly, that is something worth making space for again.

Love,

Rae

Image Credits - Iam Hogir